The Archive

Selected correspondence

Addressed to Santa · delivered here by mistake · November 17, 2026

Dear Santa, For Christmas I would like a pony and for my sister to be sent somewhere else. Not forever. Just until I'm done with the pony. Love, Maddie

— Maddie, age 6 (as told by an adult)

Misdirected
Official reply — Office of the Adversary
Illustration accompanying the reply

Dear Maddie, It appears there's been a slight detour in the postal service's usual gift routing. I've forwarded your request to the relevant jolly gift-giver at the North Pole. I must say, the temporary relocation request for your sister is a clever condition. We have a term for that in our department: "sibling-related temporal optimization." It's more common than you'd think. Remember, ponies require care and …

Read the full exchange

Addressed to Santa · delivered here by mistake · November 1, 2026

Dear Satan, I have been very good this year. I helped my mom with the dishes two times and I only hit my brother when he deserved it. For Christmas I would like a bike, a robot dinosaur, and a dog that doesn't die like the last one.

— Tyler, age 7 (as told by an adult)

Misdirected
Official reply — Office of the Adversary

Dear Tyler, I believe you meant to reach a colleague of mine. Common mistake: one transposed letter, an entire theological error. I've forwarded your request to the North Pole, though frankly his operation has gone downhill since he unionized the elves. A few notes, since you wrote. "Only hit my brother when he deserved it" is precisely the kind of self-issued moral licensing we look for in promising candidates. …

Read the full exchange